Wuhan: laboratory trail deemed "highly improbable" by WHO

Wuhan: laboratory trail deemed “highly improbable” by WHO


For several days now, WHO researchers have been dispatched to Wuhan, China, to identify the origins of Covid-19. According to their findings, leaking the coronavirus from a lab is deemed “highly unlikely.”

This mission on the origins of the transmission of the novel coronavirus to humans has struggled to take hold, as China seems very reluctant to let international specialists come to investigate. Finally, after twelve days of fieldwork in Wuhan, a team of researchers – made up of ten international scientists and five WHO experts – has just delivered its conclusions on the origin of the SARS-CoV-2 virus.

While many questions still remain unanswered, this new report ruled out one of the most frequently mentioned leads: that of the virus leaking from a P4 laboratory in the city, deemed “extremely unlikely” by the researchers.

The team came to this conclusion after conducting an objective and standardized assessment, supported by scientific literature, interviews with local researchers, and a tour of local laboratories, including that of the Wuhan Institute of Virology. This finding agrees with those of many international geneticists, pointing out that there was no telltale sign of “human tinkering” in the SARS-CoV-2 genome.

The track of the privileged intermediate host
On the other hand, the results of this investigation support the idea that the virus was transmitted to humans via a yet elusive animal intermediate host. He himself would therefore have been initially infected by a “reservoir species” (probably horseshoe bats).

Although Chinese researchers have already investigated more than 11,000 animals across the country, all have so far tested negative for SARS-CoV-2. Also, the identification of this intermediate host “will require more specific and targeted research,” said Ben Embarek, head of the WHO international team.

The team also provided some intriguing new details about the beginnings of the pandemic. After talking to doctors at the hospital where the first patients were treated, and after going to the Huanan market – which mainly sold frozen food (seafood), but also wild animals – the researchers said were able to collect epidemiological data. In this way, they were able to map the time frames and locations of the first known cases in the city.

According to them, cases of Covid-19 – which had no clear connection to this market – were indeed recorded earlier in December. This suggests that the markets could have been just places where the virus spread more easily. However, this is not necessarily where it appeared.

The WHO team is now keenly interested in further studies of animals commonly transported to and from Wuhan, including frozen products. The latter are now considered by WHO as the preferred avenue.